Beef cattle grazing on open prairie at sunrise

Country of origin labeling for beef is quietly returning in the USA, the Billings Gazette reported on June 1, 2024, through a voluntary USDA rule rather than the mandatory law Congress repealed in 2015.

How it got here

  • Senator Jon Tester of Montana proposed COOL in 2007, and Congress made it law in 2009.
  • Canada and Mexico won a WTO case, and in 2015 were cleared to impose retaliatory tariffs, so Congress pulled mandatory beef labeling.
  • R-CALF USA chief Bill Bullard says the WTO Appellate Body has been unable to rule since 2019 because the USA has blocked new appointees.

The USDA rule

In March 2024, USDA finalized a rule that lets meat carry “Product of USA” or “Made in the USA” only if the animal was born, raised, slaughtered and processed in the USA, starting in 2026. Because the label is voluntary, it does not trigger the mandatory scheme at the heart of the WTO dispute. USDA also committed to buying USA beef for its food-in-schools program.

“Biden has made the use of ‘Product of USA’ only if it is born, raised, slaughtered in the United States, that’s huge.”

Walt Schweitzer, Montana Farmers Union

A separate bill from Tester and South Dakota Republican Senator John Thune aims to bring back mandatory beef labeling in a WTO-compliant form.

FAQ

Is beef origin labeling mandatory again?

No. The 2024 USDA rule is voluntary and takes effect in 2026.

What does the label require?

The animal must be born, raised, slaughtered and processed in the USA.

Is there a bill for mandatory labels?

Yes. Senators Tester and Thune introduced a bill for WTO-compliant mandatory beef labeling.

Source & credit

Source: Billings Gazette, June 1, 2024: “Made in the USA beef label policy quietly returns”, by Tom Lutey.