A Whole Foods Market storefront in WJLA-TV I-Team footage from a 2008 report that said 365 Organic packages shown in the story were labeled Product of China.A still from the WJLA I-Team report later posted to YouTube in March 2010.

This post describes a WJLA-TV I-Team report. The questions it raises are the station’s, not claims by Made in USA News.

In May 2008, WJLA-TV in Washington, D.C., aired an I-Team investigation by reporter Roberta Baskin that questioned organic frozen vegetables sold under Whole Foods Market’s 365 Organic brand. A copy of that report was posted to YouTube on March 31, 2010, by the channel OrganicsDirect, under the title “Organic food made in China ????Whole Foods Mkt.” Made in USA News knew of the issue at the time because the team was called in to check it.

In the report, Baskin holds up 365 Organic packages and says the back of the packages, in small print, read “Product of China.” The products she names are spinach, sugar snap peas, and a mix labeled “California blend.” A shopper in the piece says, “Honestly, I would have never flipped it over to see that it was a product of China.” The I-Team also shows shoppers a package and quotes people surprised that a blend sold under a “California” name carried a China origin line on the back. Made in USA News is repeating what the video shows and says, not independently verifying those packages.

The report does not claim a court or regulator had found the products to be fake or fraudulent. It asks how shoppers can be sure food grown in China and sold with the USDA organic seal was produced to organic rules, noting that the USDA accredits private certifiers rather than inspecting imported organic food itself. Baskin says Quality Assurance International, whose seal appears on the packages shown, confirmed it “has not certified any products in China” and relied on another certifier at the farms. Linda Greer, then a senior scientist at the Natural Resources Defense Council, is quoted saying she would not buy something organic from China “with the idea that it was truly organic,” citing difficulty tracking products.

What Whole Foods said

In the WJLA report, Whole Foods officials declined an on-camera interview. The station says the company sent a statement that it relies on third-party inspectors, including a USDA-accredited agent, to meet organic standards; that it would not name the accredited agent on the farms in China; and that shoppers concerned about purchasing from China could buy domestic alternatives in its stores.

On June 6, 2008, Joe Dickson, then Whole Foods Market’s Quality Standards and Organic Programs Coordinator, published a company blog post, “Is Organic from China Possible?” He wrote: “Can organic food from China truly be organic? The short answer is ‘yes, it can,’ but the long answer is far more complex and interesting.” He added that there were “reasons we at Whole Foods Market feel good about our organic private label products from China.”

In 2011, The Boston Globe quoted Whole Foods spokesperson Heather McCready saying that as of the summer of 2010, the company was no longer sourcing any 365 Everyday Value frozen vegetables from China except frozen edamame, and that the change was a business decision after it found other suppliers, including in the United States, not a move made “because of quality or food safety concerns.” The Seattle Times later reported the same shift and separately described a 2008 television-station test of 365 organic ginger from China that found the pesticide aldicarb sulfoxide; that ginger test is not part of the video posted below.

The origin-labeling issue in the I-Team piece is the one that still matters here: shoppers were being asked to notice a “Product of China” line on the back of a package, and to question what an organic or place-name claim actually guaranteed. That is a country-of-origin problem, not a verdict on whether any one package was illegal.

The video

Credit: The report as uploaded on March 31, 2010, at Organic food made in China ????Whole Foods Mkt by OrganicsDirect. The investigation originated with WJLA-TV’s I-Team and Roberta Baskin. An archived copy of WJLA’s story page, titled “ABC 7 I-Team Investigates: Organic Foods,” is here. Poynter noted the report on May 22, 2008.

Transcript of the video

The text below is the video’s automatic captions, cleaned for punctuation and paragraph breaks. Obvious caption errors in names were corrected (the captions spelled the reporter’s name “Robera Baskin”; she is Roberta Baskin, and WJLA’s unit is the I-Team). Automatic captions can still misspeak words or miss speaker changes.

Well, tonight an I-Team investigation. What do you know about organic foods? It’s pesticide-free. It’s more expensive, but it’s worth it, right? Ah, not necessarily. Would you believe organically grown in China? How organic can that possibly be? Well, the I-Team’s Roberta Baskin has been investigating and she’s got some questions for one major food chain. Tell us about that.

It’s Whole Foods. It’s the leading food retailer selling the image that local and organic is better for the environment and better for you. But is that in fact what the customer is getting? With 175 stores, Whole Foods is the undisputed leader in organic foods and promotes locally grown. But the I-Team has found that much of Whole Foods organics are imported from China.

“Honestly, I would have never flipped it over to see that it was a product of China.”

Spinach, sugar snap peas, and would you believe California blend vegetables, all listed under the Whole Foods brand 365 Organic. And on the back in small print, Product of China. Organic ensures pesticide-free, environmentally friendly conditions. But how do we even know the food is organic? Food sold in this country must be approved by the U.S. Department of Agriculture before they can display the organic label.

“The oversight that they have in China is not the same kind of supervision that we have in the United States.”

But the USDA doesn’t inspect imported foods. It certifies private inspectors to do the job. Whole Foods employs a company called Quality Assurance International. But the company confirms QAI has not certified any products in China. They rely on another certifier on the farms. Yet there’s the QAI certification seal, the USDA seal, and Product of China, all on the same Whole Foods package.

“So that you have to ask yourself the question, how would they ever know if the organic rules are being followed?”

Organic California stir fry from China. Linda Greer is a senior scientist at the Natural Resources Defense Council, an environmental advocacy group. She’s been to farms in China.

“I wouldn’t buy something organic from China with the idea that it was truly organic.”

Why not?

“The reason is because we’ve had such a difficult time tracking things.”

There’s growing concern about the quality of food from China. Already this year, the Food and Drug Administration, which checks for food safety, stopped 260 shipments of foods like strawberries contaminated with bad pesticides, bacteria, or filth.

“I think it’s probably not an accident that Product of China is in such small type.”

The I-Team obtained this internal company document from Whole Foods, listing the country of origin for hundreds of its products, dozens of organics, many from China. Everything from asparagus spears to pine nuts to creamy peanut butter. Whole Foods wouldn’t allow our cameras in its store. So, we bought the products and stepped outside to show shoppers.

“It’s definitely misleading. And if they were proud of it being from China, it would be displayed on the front, I’m sure.”

Shoppers we talked to were most surprised by Whole Foods organic California blend of cauliflower, carrots, and broccoli.

“If they’re going to put in bold California on the label, they shouldn’t put China in fine print on the back.”

We also went to the Fresh Farm Markets at Dupont Circle where people take their organic food very seriously.

“Oh, but it’s from China. What a travesty. Distributed by Whole Foods, Product of China. Whoa, look at that.”

Bernardine Prince, founder of this market, says Whole Foods shoppers should be asking questions.

“The first thing I would do is say, ‘Okay, Whole Foods, is this really organic? And how do you know it’s organic? Because I don’t know.'”

Linda Greer says people should be asking the government questions, “and consumers are probably blissfully unaware that the government is not protecting them.”

Whole Foods officials declined to be interviewed for our report. They sent a statement to say that they rely on third-party inspectors, which includes a USDA-accredited agent to meet the organic standards. But Whole Foods would not tell us who this third-party accredited agent is on the farms in China. And Whole Foods also says that shoppers who are concerned about purchasing from China can purchase domestic alternatives in their stores.

But if you want to know, well then you can go to our website and click on wjla.com and then click on the I-Team and you can get the country of origin list that says do not distribute this list right here. You got the whole thing on the website. Wow. That’s a perfect way if you have a specific product you want to know the background. Very good. And there’s a lot here too. All right. Check it out.