The “Made in America Store” in Elma, New York, which sold only USA-made products, has closed after 16 years, Yahoo Finance reported on May 5, 2026.
What happened
- The company called the closure a “strategic restructuring” after a decision to sell the building.
- Its online store is paused, with plans to relaunch once a new location is set.
- The store opened in 2010 and became a regional draw for shoppers who wanted USA-made goods.
“This is not a goodbye, but rather a strategic restructuring that allows us to thoughtfully plan for the future.”
The “Made in America Store,” public announcement
The closure comes as more stores close nationwide. Yahoo Finance cited Coresight Research data showing store closures rose 67% in 2025. It also cited a November 2024 Morning Consult poll for the Alliance for American Manufacturing, which found 60% of Americans tried to buy USA-made products in the past year and 82% would buy more if they were easier to identify.
Why it matters for Made in USA
The store was one of the best-known retailers selling only USA-made goods. Its founder, Mark Andol, died in July 2025. See our report. Shoppers say they want USA-made goods, but a store selling only those products still faces tight margins and higher costs. Tariffs on imported parts also raise prices for USA makers.
FAQ
Is the “Made in America Store” gone for good?
The owners say they intend to reopen at a new location when circumstances allow.
Why did it close?
The company called it a strategic restructuring after deciding to sell the building.
Can I still order online?
The online store is paused during the transition, according to the company.
Source & credit
Originally reported by Yahoo Finance (Fernanda Tronco), May 5, 2026: “The Made in America Store shuts down ahead of America’s 250th birthday”