Still from a 2026 Taste Guide investigation of Made in USA and Product of USA food labels

On October 29, 2026, The Taste Guide posted a 14-minute investigation under the title “We Investigated “Made in America” Food Labels — Most Aren’t.” The video is a walk through grocery-aisle flags and origin lines, and a useful reminder that “Made in USA” and “Product of USA” are not the same rule and are not even enforced by the same agency. The legal points below are taken from the underlying federal sources, not from the YouTube title alone.

For most consumer products, the Federal Trade Commission polices unqualified Made in USA claims under the Made in USA Labeling Rule, 16 CFR Part 323, which became effective on August 13, 2021. A product advertised as Made in USA must be all or virtually all made in the United States. For meat, poultry and egg products, origin wording on the label is a USDA Food Safety and Inspection Service matter. FSIS’s final rule on voluntary “Product of USA” and similar U.S.-origin claims, published in the Federal Register on March 18, 2024, provides that those claims may be used only if the product is derived from animals born, raised, slaughtered and processed in the United States. The compliance date was January 1, 2026. U.S. Customs and Border Protection enforces country-of-origin marking on imports; the Food and Drug Administration, as the video notes, largely defers to Customs on origin labeling in its compliance policy guidance.

The Taste Guide is right that one of the widest gaps was on meat. After Congress repealed mandatory country-of-origin labeling for muscle cuts and ground beef and pork in the Consolidated Appropriations Act, 2016, a “Product of USA” line could still appear on meat that had only been processed in the United States. The 2024 FSIS rule is what closed that voluntary-claim loophole, as of January 1, 2026. It did not restore mandatory COOL for beef and pork. At the fish counter and in the produce section, origin information remains required under other programs. The video also notes a point Customs has long made: repackaging an imported food in the United States does not, by itself, change its country of origin.

The Taste Guide closes with a five-second checklist: read the actual words, not just the flag; find the country-of-origin line, usually near the ingredients or the address block; remember what is and is not required, especially for beef and pork; watch for qualifiers such as “with imported ingredients”; and report a label that looks false to the FTC. That is practical advice. The official standard for an unqualified Made in USA claim is still the Commission’s, and the official standard for a voluntary “Product of USA” claim on FSIS-regulated meat is now the born-raised-slaughtered-and-processed test.

The video

Credit: We Investigated “Made in America” Food Labels — Most Aren’t, posted October 29, 2026, by The Taste Guide. Official sources for the rules discussed: the FTC Made in USA Labeling Rule; the USDA FSIS final rule on voluntary U.S.-origin claims and the Federal Register notice of March 18, 2024.

Transcript excerpt

The text below is from the video’s automatic captions, lightly cleaned for punctuation. The full video runs more than 14 minutes; this is an excerpt of the opening argument and the closing checklist, not a complete transcript. Automatic captions can still misspeak words.

Picture this. You’re walking through the grocery store, doing what a lot of us do when we’re trying to spend our money well. You pick up a package of chicken sausage or a bag of frozen shrimp or a jar of something with a little red barn on the label, and there it is, an American flag. Maybe the words “Product of USA.” You feel good about it. You drop it in the cart. You just bought American — or did you? Because over the past few weeks, we’ve been digging through federal regulations, customs rulings and agency guidance, and what we found is that Made in USA and Product of USA are not the same rule. They’re not even enforced by the same agency. And for years, one of those labels was allowed on meat from animals that were born, raised and slaughtered in another country. So how does that happen? Who actually decides what American means on a food label? And when you look at what the law really requires, how many of those flags are telling you the whole story? Stick around, because by the end of this video, you’ll know exactly where the loopholes are and how to spot them in about 5 seconds.

Who decides what American means? Let’s start with the basics, because this is where most of the confusion lives. When you see Made in USA on a package, you’d assume there’s one national definition. There isn’t. There’s the Federal Trade Commission, which polices Made in USA claims on most products. There’s the USDA’s Food Safety and Inspection Service, which handles meat, poultry and egg products. And there’s Customs and Border Protection, which cares about what crosses the border and how it’s marked. Three agencies, three sets of rules. Even the FDA, the agency you’d expect to be in charge of food labels, mostly steps aside on this one. Its own compliance policy says that on origin labeling, it defers to Customs.

From the closing checklist, as stated in the video: first, read the words, not just the flag. Second, find the country-of-origin statement with a country name, usually near the ingredients or the address block; if a product was imported and repackaged, that line is the one that tells the truth. Third, remember what’s covered: at the fish counter and in the produce section, origin information is required; beef and pork are the exception, so for those, check the company’s website or ask the butcher. Fourth, look at the ingredient list on anything labeled Made in USA. “A truly American product shouldn’t need much explaining. If the label has to add a qualifier like ‘with imported ingredients,’ that tells you the company knows exactly where the line is.” And fifth, if a label looks flat-out false, report it to the FTC.

“The good news is that the rules are better than they were. That Product of USA change is real, and it closes one of the biggest gaps. The FTC standard is strict. Customs law says repackaging doesn’t erase an import’s origin. The bad news is that most of this system runs on voluntary claims, split between agencies, with a giant exception for beef and pork. And a label that is technically legal can still leave you with a completely wrong picture in your head. I don’t think you should stop trying to buy American if that matters to you. I think you should do it with your eyes open. Read the words, find the country, and don’t let a little flag do your thinking for you.”