Redman & Associates LLC of Rogers, Arkansas, sued its longtime overseas manufacturer, Sales Chief Enterprise Co., on September 5, 2014, claiming the company tried to block its plan to move production of children’s ride-on toy cars to the USA for Walmart.
The lawsuit
- The suit, filed in federal court in Fayetteville, Arkansas, seeks more than $20 million for alleged breach of contract, tortious interference, misuse of trade secrets and breach of warranty, Plastics News reported.
- Redman says the two companies did $62 million of business since March 2012 on 60-day payment terms. In May, it says, Sales Chief revoked its credit and demanded immediate payment, including for goods already shipped.
- Redman CEO Mel Redman said meeting that demand would cost about $10 million and stopped toys from reaching Walmart shelves before the holiday season.
- “Evidently, Chinese manufacturers are extremely resistant to any effort by American companies to re-domesticate manufacturing,” the complaint says.
Ellen Liu, Sales Chief’s general manager, told Plastics News that the company was preparing its legal response and that its business issues with Redman were not related to Walmart’s pledge to buy an additional $250 billion in USA-made goods over 10 years.
The USA production plan
Redman planned to move all production of a six-volt, battery-powered ride-on vehicle to Arkansas over three years. Its Nuvzn Technologies unit worked with Bentonville Plastics, which molded the main body, and Redman assembled and shipped the toys. The plan received $2 million from the state, Arkansas Business reported. Nuvzn laid off 14 workers on the day the suit was filed.
“This is the first time I’ve seen a Chinese company retaliating against the Made in USA initiative,” said Grant Tennille, executive director of the Arkansas Economic Development Commission.
Source & credit
Source: Plastics News: “Toy supplier sues maker in reshoring fight”, by Catherine Kavanaugh, September 15, 2014.
Additional source: Arkansas Business: “14 Laid Off By Toy Car Maker in Blow to Wal-Mart’s ‘Made in USA’ Initiative”, September 5, 2014.

